Choosing The Right Fishing Bait Colors - A Guide To Color Selection

How to pick the right color of bait when fishing

Fishing is as much an art as it is a science. One of the most debated topics among anglers is the selection of bait colors. With a plethora of options available, how does one decide which hue will be the most effective? In this article, we'll explore the factors to consider when choosing fishing bait colors, ensuring you make the best choice for your fishing conditions.

Garlic is also another practice used to help attract fish, and to mask our scent. But let's chat about looking at the water to determine your bait colors. Remember, an old age trick states, "dark water = dark color, clean water = light color", but we take it a step further, which we will explain below.

1. Understand the Water Clarity

The clarity of the water plays a significant role in determining which bait colors will be most visible to fish.

  • Clear Water: In clear water conditions, natural and subtle colors like green pumpkin, watermelon, and shad tend to work best. These colors mimic the natural prey of fish and don't stand out too much, making them more appealing.

  • Murky or Stained Water: In darker waters, you'll want to use brighter and more vibrant colors like chartreuse, neon orange, or bright yellow. These colors are more visible in low-light conditions and can attract fish from a distance.

2. Consider the Weather and Light Conditions

  • Sunny Days: On bright days, reflective or metallic colors like silver, gold, or chrome can be effective as they mimic the shiny appearance of baitfish. The sunlight causes these baits to flash, attracting predatory fish.

  • Cloudy or Overcast Days: On overcast days, darker colors like black, blue, or purple can create a silhouette against the lighter sky, making it easier for fish to spot the bait.

3. Think About the Natural Prey

It's essential to consider the natural diet of the fish you're targeting. If the primary food source is bluegill, for instance, then baits that resemble the colors of a bluegill (greens and blues) might be more effective. Similarly, if shad are prevalent, silver and white baits can be a good choice.

4. Experiment with Contrasting Colors

Sometimes, a two-tone bait with contrasting colors can be incredibly effective. For example, a bait with a darker back and a lighter belly can mimic many types of prey fish. This contrast can make the bait more noticeable and appealing to predatory fish.

5. Don't Forget About Fluorescent Colors

In deeper waters where light penetration is minimal, fluorescent colors can be a game-changer. These colors, like bright pink or neon green, can glow in the dark depths, attracting fish from afar.

6. Trust Your Instincts and Observe

While these guidelines can provide a starting point, every fishing environment is unique. It's essential to observe the behavior of the fish and adjust your bait colors accordingly. If a particular color isn't working, don't hesitate to switch it up. Sometimes, even a slight change in shade can make a big difference.

So, here are some of the color suggestions we have: 

  • Dark Water - Blue sky, green pumpkin, pumpkin, orange pumpkin, black, dark gree. 
  • Clean water - white, blue silver flake, green sliver flake, green monster, orange silver flake.

I could keep going on with colors, weather conditions and more, but you'll have to fully determine what is best for you and your fishing conditions, but you can see all the colors and sizes we have available here

Use the code nicecatch at checkout for 25% off your order. 


Choosing the right fishing bait color is a combination of understanding the environment, considering the natural prey, and a bit of trial and error. By paying attention to the factors mentioned above and being willing to experiment, you can increase your chances of success on the water. Remember, while color is crucial, other factors like bait movement, size, and presentation also play a significant role in attracting fish. So, arm yourself with a variety of colors and let the fish tell you what they prefer on any given day. Happy fishing!